Engage AI Alternatives: Best LinkedIn Comment Tools in 2025
Junaid Khalid
Contents
You're evaluating Engage AI. Or maybe you've already subscribed but aren't fully satisfied. The pricing feels steep ($19-99/month), the AI quality isn't matching your voice, or you want features Engage AI doesn't offer.
You're not alone. Engage AI is popular, but it's not the only LinkedIn comment tool—and for many users, it's not the best fit.
This guide examines five Engage AI alternatives across different price points and feature sets. You'll discover which tools deliver better AI quality, which offer more features for the money, and which fit specific use cases Engage AI doesn't serve well.
By the end, you'll know exactly which LinkedIn comment tool matches your needs without overpaying or settling for mediocre AI.
Why Look for Engage AI Alternatives?
Pricing concerns ($19-99/month adds up)
Engage AI's pricing tiers:
- Basic: $19/month
- Pro: $39/month
- Premium: $99/month
For individual professionals, $228-1,188 annually for comment assistance alone is a significant investment—especially when cheaper alternatives deliver comparable (or better) results.
AI quality inconsistency
Common complaints about Engage AI's comment suggestions:
- Comments feel templated despite claiming AI personalization
- Generic phrases appear frequently ("Great insight!", "Thanks for sharing!")
- Doesn't adapt well to user's unique voice
- Struggles with nuanced or technical posts
Limited platform support
Engage AI focuses exclusively on LinkedIn. If you also engage on Twitter, Reddit, or other platforms, you need separate tools.
What users want from an Engage AI alternative:
- Better AI quality that sounds more human
- Lower pricing (especially for solo users)
- Multi-platform support
- Better voice adaptation
- More customization options
Top 5 Engage AI Alternatives
#1 LigoAI - Best AI Quality & Multi-Platform Support
What it is: Chrome extension providing AI-generated comments across LinkedIn, Twitter, Reddit, and Facebook.
vs Engage AI:
- AI Quality: LigoAI uses GPT-4-class models; more contextually aware
- Pricing: Free trial (30 comments) vs Engage AI's $19+ monthly
- Platforms: Multi-platform vs LinkedIn-only
- Voice Learning: Adapts during 30-comment trial
Key features:
- Context-aware comment generation
- Voice learning and adaptation
- Manual trigger (you approve every comment)
- Works across 4 platforms
- No LinkedIn ban risk
Pricing: Free trial (30 comments), then paid plans
Best for: Professionals who want premium AI quality, multi-platform support, and ability to test before committing.
Pros:
- Better AI quality than Engage AI
- Free trial to test voice adaptation
- Multi-platform (LinkedIn, Twitter, Reddit, Facebook)
- Simpler interface
- Lower ban risk (manual approval)
Cons:
- No CRM/lead tracking features
- Free trial limited to 30 comments
- No team features
Direct comparison: If you use Engage AI primarily for comment generation (not CRM features), LigoAI delivers better AI at better value.
#2 ChatGPT + Manual Workflow - Best Free Alternative
What it is: Using ChatGPT to generate comment suggestions, then manually posting on LinkedIn.
vs Engage AI:
- Cost: Free (GPT-3.5) or $20/month (GPT-4) vs $19-99/month
- AI Quality: GPT-4 exceeds Engage AI's quality
- Workflow: Manual copy-paste vs integrated extension
How it works:
- Copy LinkedIn post text
- Paste into ChatGPT with prompt
- Review and customize suggestion
- Paste into LinkedIn and post
Pricing: Free (GPT-3.5) or $20/month (ChatGPT Plus)
Best for: Budget-conscious users who don't mind manual workflows.
Pros:
- Cheapest option (potentially free)
- Best AI quality (GPT-4)
- Maximum customization
- Works for all platforms
Cons:
- Manual copy-paste is tedious
- No LinkedIn integration
- Slower than browser extensions
- No voice learning
Verdict: Best free option, but workflow friction makes it impractical for high-volume commenting (15+ daily).
#3 Taplio Comment Generator - Best All-in-One Platform
What it is: Comment generation as part of Taplio's comprehensive LinkedIn platform.
vs Engage AI:
- Features: All-in-one (scheduling, analytics, CRM) vs comment-focused
- Pricing: $39-199/month vs $19-99/month
- Use Case: Full platform vs specialized tool
Taplio includes:
- AI comment generator
- Post scheduling
- Content library
- Analytics dashboard
- Carousel maker
- LinkedIn CRM
Pricing: $39-199/month
Best for: Users who need multiple LinkedIn tools and will use 5+ features regularly.
Pros:
- Comprehensive feature set
- Good if you use multiple tools
- Team collaboration features
- Unified platform
Cons:
- Expensive if you only need comments
- Feature overwhelm
- Steep learning curve
- Overkill for focused use cases
Verdict: Choose Taplio over Engage AI only if you'll actually use scheduling, analytics, and content creation features. Otherwise, it's expensive overkill.
#4 Dux-Soup - Best for Sales-Focused Automation
What it is: LinkedIn automation tool including profile visits, connection requests, messaging, and commenting.
vs Engage AI:
- Focus: Sales automation vs engagement
- Automation Level: More aggressive vs conservative
- Risk: Higher ban risk vs lower risk
Key features:
- Automated profile visits
- Connection request campaigns
- Message sequences
- Auto-commenting (template-based)
- CRM integration
Pricing: $14.99-55/month
Best for: B2B sales professionals who want outreach automation beyond just commenting.
Important warning: Higher LinkedIn ban risk than Engage AI or LigoAI due to more aggressive automation.
Pros:
- Cheaper than Engage AI
- More features (connection requests, messages)
- Good for sales workflows
- CRM integration
Cons:
- Higher ban risk
- Comments are template-based (not AI-generated)
- Steeper learning curve
- Not ideal for personal brand building
Verdict: Choose Dux-Soup if you need full sales automation. Avoid if you only want comment assistance—it's riskier and comments are lower quality.
#5 DIY: Custom GPT + Browser Automation
What it is: Building your own comment tool using ChatGPT API and basic automation scripts.
vs Engage AI:
- Cost: Pay-per-use (~$0.02-0.05/comment) vs $19-99/month flat fee
- Customization: Unlimited vs pre-built features
- Effort: High setup vs plug-and-play
How it works:
- Use ChatGPT API for comment generation
- Build simple Chrome extension or bookmarklet
- Automate parts of workflow (optional)
Pricing: ChatGPT API costs ~$0.02-0.05 per comment (volume dependent)
Best for: Technical users who want maximum control and minimum cost at scale.
Pros:
- Cheapest at high volume
- Complete customization
- Best AI quality (GPT-4 API)
- Learning experience
Cons:
- Requires technical skills
- Time investment to build
- Maintenance burden
- No support
Verdict: Only pursue if you enjoy building tools. For 99% of users, pre-built solutions (LigoAI, ChatGPT manual) save time and frustration.
Feature Comparison Table
| Feature | LigoAI | ChatGPT Manual | Taplio | Dux-Soup | DIY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free trial + paid | Free-$20/mo | $39-199/mo | $15-55/mo | API costs |
| AI Quality | Excellent | Excellent | Good | Template-only | Excellent |
| LinkedIn Integration | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | Custom |
| Multi-Platform | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ | Custom |
| Voice Learning | ✅ | Limited | Limited | ❌ | Custom |
| Setup Time | 2 min | 0 min | 30 min | 15 min | Hours |
| Ban Risk | Very Low | None | Low | Medium-High | Low |
| CRM Features | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | Custom |
| Best For | AI quality seekers | Budget users | All-in-one | Sales automation | Developers |
vs Engage AI comparison:
| Feature | LigoAI | Engage AI |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free trial + paid | $19-99/mo |
| AI Quality | Excellent (GPT-4-class) | Good |
| Platforms | 4 platforms | LinkedIn only |
| Voice Adaptation | Strong | Moderate |
| CRM/Lead Tracking | ❌ | ✅ |
| Free Trial | 30 comments | Limited |
| Ban Risk | Very Low | Low |
How to Choose the Right Engage AI Alternative
Choose LigoAI if: ✓ AI quality is your top priority ✓ You want multi-platform support (Twitter, Reddit, Facebook) ✓ You want to test with a meaningful free trial ✓ You don't need CRM/lead tracking features ✓ You prefer simple, focused tools
Choose ChatGPT Manual if: ✓ Budget is your primary concern ✓ You're comfortable with manual workflows ✓ You comment 5-10 times daily (low volume) ✓ You want the best AI quality regardless of convenience
Choose Taplio if: ✓ You need full LinkedIn platform (scheduling, analytics, carousels) ✓ You'll use 5+ features regularly ✓ Budget isn't a constraint ($39-199/month is acceptable) ✓ You prefer all-in-one solutions
Choose Dux-Soup if: ✓ You need sales automation (connection requests, messages) ✓ Comment quality is secondary to volume ✓ You're comfortable with higher ban risk ✓ You run active B2B outreach campaigns
Stay with Engage AI if: ✓ You heavily use the CRM/lead tracking features ✓ You're satisfied with current AI quality ✓ You're already in their ecosystem
Migration Guide: Switching from Engage AI
Step 1: Identify what you actually use
Review your Engage AI usage:
- Do you use lead tracking features? (If yes, consider Taplio or Dux-Soup)
- Do you only use comment generation? (If yes, LigoAI or ChatGPT)
- How many comments daily? (High volume = LigoAI, Low volume = ChatGPT)
Step 2: Test alternatives with free trials
Week 1: Try LigoAI's 30-comment free trial
- Compare AI quality to Engage AI
- Test voice adaptation
- Measure engagement results
Week 2: Try ChatGPT manual workflow (if budget-focused)
- Test with 5-10 comments
- Evaluate if manual workflow is acceptable
Step 3: Compare results
Metrics to track:
- Comment quality (your subjective assessment)
- Reply rate on your comments
- Time per comment
- Profile visits generated
- Overall satisfaction
Step 4: Make the switch
If alternative meets needs:
- Cancel Engage AI before next billing cycle
- Export any data you need (prospect lists, etc.)
- Migrate to new tool
Real User Switching Stories
Case Study: Solo consultant switched to LigoAI
David paid $39/month for Engage AI. Primary use: commenting on prospects' posts.
He switched to LigoAI because:
- Better AI quality ("sounds more like me")
- Also uses Twitter for engagement (LigoAI works there too)
- Free trial let him test thoroughly
Result: Saved $468/year, better AI quality, same engagement results.
Case Study: Sales team stayed with Engage AI
Marketing agency with 5 SDRs. Used Engage AI's lead tracking features heavily.
They evaluated LigoAI but stayed with Engage AI because:
- Needed prospect tracking
- Team features were valuable
- Already integrated into workflow
Key learning: If you use Engage AI's CRM features, alternatives may not fully replace it.
Pricing Comparison: 1-Year Cost
| Tool | Annual Cost | What You Get |
|---|---|---|
| Engage AI Basic | $228/year | Comment AI + basic features |
| Engage AI Pro | $468/year | Comment AI + lead tracking |
| LigoAI | Free trial + paid | Comment AI + multi-platform |
| ChatGPT Plus | $240/year | Manual workflow, best AI |
| Taplio | $468-2,388/year | Full LinkedIn platform |
| Dux-Soup | $180-660/year | Sales automation |
Savings potential: Switching from Engage AI ($468/year) to LigoAI or ChatGPT can save $228-468 annually while maintaining or improving AI quality.
Start Testing Engage AI Alternatives Today
The best way to find your ideal LinkedIn comment tool is hands-on testing.
Recommended approach:
- Try LigoAI's free trial (30 comments) - Test premium AI quality risk-free
- Try ChatGPT manual workflow - See if free option works for your volume
- Compare to current Engage AI experience - Is AI better? Worse? Same?
- Decide based on data, not assumptions
Most users discover they either:
- Get better AI quality with LigoAI
- Save money with ChatGPT (if low volume)
- Actually need Engage AI's CRM features (stay)
Start with LigoAI Free Trial (30 Comments)
Final Verdict: Is Engage AI Still Worth It?
Engage AI is worth keeping if:
- You use lead tracking/CRM features regularly
- You're satisfied with AI quality
- $19-99/month fits your budget
- You're deeply integrated
Switch to an alternative if:
- You only use comment generation (don't need CRM)
- AI quality doesn't match your voice
- You want multi-platform support
- Budget is a concern
The LinkedIn comment tool landscape is competitive. You no longer have to choose between "expensive mediocre tool" or "no tool at all." Better AI quality and better pricing exist—if you're willing to test alternatives.
Related Resources
About the Author
Junaid Khalid
I have helped 50,000+ professionals with building a personal brand on LinkedIn through my content and products, and directly consulted dozens of businesses in building a Founder Brand and Employee Advocacy Program to grow their business via LinkedIn